Corporal Punishment, child welfare and restraints.

Two weeks ago, my elementary school principal, Ernie Ross, passed away.   Mr. Ross was my principal for 3rd, 4th and 5th grades at Mountain View Elementary school.  I, like many of my classmates, had great fear of Mr. Ross.  He manned a stop light in the lunch room that would move from green to yellow to red as the noise level rose during the lunch period.  At times he would walk around the lunchroom carrying his paddle.  Rumors abounded among my classmates about Mr. Ross’s accuracy and strength in utilizing his paddle.  He was rumored to have a paddle with holes to make the swing swifter.

I was deathly afraid of him.  I had been spanked at home, and was quite intimate with the effects of my father’s belt. The belt, however, was the limit of my experience with spanking implements.  I  imagined the paddle, and especially the paddle with holes was 10 times worse.  Although never said, I knew if I got spanked at school, the school punishment would be the least of my problems.  I’m sure I would have been one with my father’s belt.

Once, in 4th grade, I was sent to Mr. Ross’s office.   I was often quick at completing my school work, and when bored would start chit-chatting with the kids nearby.  Despite several warnings from my teacher, Mrs. Coffey, I continued to talk away.    Mrs. Coffey didn’t have many options for punishment.  I already had to stay in most recesses because I couldn’t pass the stupid multiplication time test with 100% accuracy.   Fed up, she ordered me to go see Mr. Ross.  I don’t think I was ever so frightened in my entire school career.   I was sure I was going to experience the paddle, and I felt like throwing up.  When I got to the office, the school secretary told me to sit on a bench outside Mr. Ross’s office.  I sat, and sat, and sat.  With each passing minute, my fear grew.  I never did see Mr. Ross that day, and after a period of time, I was sent back to my classroom.  The experience remains vivid in my mind 30 years later.

Today I was reading a New York Times article about the decline of corporal punishment in schools.  Colorado is among the states where the practice is still legal, but rarely used.  Many states, including Texas and New Mexico are considering bans of the practice during the current legislative season.  In Colorado, not only is corporal punishment by schools legal, but parents can also use corporal punishment, with some limits.  Despite the law allowing corporal punishment, the first thing that happens in most child protection cases is that the court orders the parent(s) to not use any physical discipline.   Foster parents are also not allowed to use physical discipline.

The hypocrisy of all this struck me as I was reading the Times article.  The states that are banning the practice are doing so because of the demonstrated harm to children.  It doesn’t seem like the use of corporal punishment, albeit legal, is a big issue in Colorado.   However the use of prone restraints not only harms children and people with developmental and mental disabilities, but it kills them. 

Colorado residential facilities are allowed to use physical discipline on children and adults with developmental and mental disabilities.  These facilities call it restraint.  They claim restraint is necessary to protect staff and residents.  There are times that it is necessary to restrain out of control people, but many, if not most restraints can be avoided with proper staff training.  Even more can be avoided with facility policies that allow the out of control person to work out their issues in a secure location, where staff and other residents are at a safe distance.  These positive behavioral supports and interventions not only work, but they save lives.  The hitch, it costs more than to simply use physical restraint.  Despite the cost, there is no excuse for facilities that are paid $80, $90, $100 a day or  more choose restraints over a more humane, effective and safe behavioral intervention approach.woman using deadly prone restraint technique on a teen

When a person is causing serious self-injury during an out of control incident, a safe and properly executed restraint may be indicated.   If a person is out of control in the community, a safe and properly executed restraint may be necessary to protect the individual and the community.   What is never indicated is a prone restrain where a person is restrained face down with their arms behind their back, or in any other position that places the individual at risk of positional asphyxia.

Over the years well-publicized deaths due to improper restraints have led Colorado lawmakers to restrict restraint practice. In 1993 Casey Collier, a teen with autism, died at the hands of his residential facility providers at the Cleo Wallace Center in Westminster, Colorado.  Casey, a foster child, was killed by the system that was intended to protect him.  In 1999, in part in response to Casey and others’ deaths, Colorado passed the “Protection of Persons from Restraint Act.”  This Act delineates when and how restraints may be used in schools, and facilities serving children in foster care, as well as people with developmental and mental disabilities.

Despite the Act, children and people with disabilities still die from the use of restraints in facilities.  Orlena Parker died at the Colorado Springs  Devereux Cleo Wallace facility in 2003 after 6 or 7 adults pinned her down during an out of control incident.   A Denver news station conducted an investigation into four deaths of epople with disabilities in state, or state funded, facilities.  All four people died as a result of improper restraints, particularly prone restraints.   In response to these deaths, a bill was introduced to amend the Protection of Persons from Restraint Act to prohibit many forms of dangerous prone restraint.  Sadly this bill died in committee, after extensive lobbying efforts by facilities who prefer to use the deadly and less costly restraints.

It seems money and power trump what is best for children and people with disabilities.

Share Button

Comments

  1. There is definately a great deal to know about this topic.
    I like all the points you have made.

  2. Thank you for any other fantastic article. Where else may
    just anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect way of writing?
    I’ve a presentation next week, and I am at the search for such information.

  3. Potentially you have made use of by obtaining the Crazy shirts
    Coupon Code merely to recognize that you can not utilize this
    less expensive it offers? Anybody whom vendors on the web straightforward Crazy shirts Coupon Code would’ve professional this problem.

    These type of Crazy shirts Coupon Code will typically be very valued merely by internet purchasers
    thinking about that they make them become troubles in addition to competence referring to essential earnings.

    You can avoid basically any kind of troubles in addition to using a Crazy shirts Coupon Code
    has to you understand they will certainly to make essential strategies as
    opposed to they will. A lot of the problems absolutely eaten with
    the aid of customers include:.

    Obtaining the done Crazy shirts Coupon Code: Many Crazy shirts Coupon Code
    use an occasion time-frame across that they can halt made use of to obtain a more affordable price or simply
    simply handy method. With each other, an added person instead back could possibly acquire fortuitous
    utilizing your Crazy shirts Coupon Code that include passed her expiration day
    when your business have actually actually never ever deactivated this kind of decrease.

    Not necessarily checking out the Crazy shirts Coupon Code entirely.
    Before choosing to exactly what precisely kind of Crazy shirts Coupon Code
    have to be utilized any person efficiently can well aren’t enjoyed
    discovered locate the most from making use of. You can not assume practically all Crazy shirts Coupon Code provide
    a developed lower.

    Going down obtaining a particular Crazy shirts Coupon Code.
    On the other hand, you can use software application applications keeping
    to the authentic Crazy shirts Coupon Code so that you could utilize
    them even with the truth that critical.

    When you are obtaining online, you could have a huge amount remarkable
    supplies of money on a regular month-to-month basis making use
    of the ideal Crazy shirts Coupon Code. Getting this sort of Crazy shirts Coupon Code could not be
    simple. Have to be reality, you’re most likely to be spending lots of
    impartial trying to find individuals Crazy shirts Coupon Code.

    You have to acknowledge using Crazy shirts Coupon Code in the liable
    technique or perhaps you carry out uncover youself to obtain spending a
    more considerable expense for anyone opportunities.
    Since to recognize an instead a lot of components being made effortlessly supplied with
    a small asking cost as an outcome of Crazy shirts Coupon Code, it does not generate simply.

    Perhaps you have used by getting the Crazy shirts Coupon Code just to
    acknowledge that you can not use this more economical it offers?
    Since they make them become issues along with effectiveness connecting to relevant revenues, these sort of Crazy shirts Coupon Code will frequently be very
    cherished simply by web purchasers.

    Acquiring the done Crazy shirts Coupon Code: The majority of Crazy shirts Coupon Code use an event time-frame all over that they might quit used to obtain a more cost effective expenditure
    or merely simply helpful strategy. Before preferring to
    what specifically type of Crazy shirts Coupon Code ought to be utilized anybody effectively could
    well aren’t enjoyed discovered locate the most from
    making use of.

    Perhaps you have utilized by acquiring the Crazy shirts Coupon Code
    just to recognize that you can not use this cheaper it offers?
    These types of Crazy shirts Coupon Code will generally be incredibly valued just by web purchasers taking into consideration that they make
    them end up being issues in addition to know-how referring to
    pertinent revenues.

    Prior to opting to just what precisely type of Crazy shirts Coupon Code should be made use
    of any person effectively could well aren’t thrilled to learned discover the most from taking advantage of.

    You could have a huge amount wonderful deals of cash
    on a regular month-to-month basis taking advantage of the best Crazy
    shirts Coupon Code when you are getting online.

    Possibly you have made use of by getting the Crazy shirts Coupon Code simply to acknowledge that you
    can not use this cheaper it provides? These kinds
    of Crazy shirts Coupon Code will normally be extremely valued just by net purchasers taking into consideration that they make them become
    issues in addition to competence referring to significant
    profits.

    Prior to picking to exactly what precisely kind of Crazy shirts Coupon Code should be made use of any person successfully could
    well aren’t delighted to discovered find the most from making usage
    of. When you are getting online, you can have a big quantity wonderful deals of money on a regular regular monthly basis utilizing
    the right Crazy shirts Coupon Code.

  4. What’s up everyone, it’s my first go to see at this website, and paragraph is actually fruitful in support of me, keep up posting such posts.

  5. Hello there, You’ve done a fantastic job. I’ll certainly digg it and personally recommend
    to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited
    from this site.

  6. This paragraph is in fact a fastidious one it
    assists new the web people, who are wishing for blogging.

  7. Quality content is the important to interest the people
    to pay a quick visit the site, that’s what this website is providing.

Speak Your Mind

*